AI in Education: Where Human Judgment Still Matters

Matthew Pierce, Growth and Content Marketing Manager for TechSmith, explains where human judgment still matters when AI is deployed in education. This article originally appeared in Insight Jam, an enterprise IT community that enables human conversation on AI.
AI is quickly becoming an important tool in the educator’s toolkit, with applications ranging from researching course materials to editing lecture videos. But not every task benefits from artificial intelligence, and unlike most other tools, it requires a great deal of diligence to figure out where these tools can save time without creating more work or compromising the quality of instruction.
In today’s classrooms, AI is most useful as a starting point, helping educators with admin, as well as developing and refining materials, while leaving the expertise, judgment, and perspective that make teaching effective in human hands.
Where AI Earns Its Keep
Professors spend an average of 10 to 15 hours per week on administrative tasks that take time away from teaching, making these activities a practical starting point for AI support. Curriculum research is one example. When developing a course, instructors must connect academic concepts with research and current industry case studies. Finding material can take days of preparation, a process that becomes especially time-consuming when courses require updates each semester to stay relevant. AI-based tools can accelerate the search by helping instructors identify sources, summarize findings, and locate supporting references.
But finding a source is not the same as determining its utility. Educators still need to verify and assess whether the material supports learning objectives. Another example where AI can assist is in video production. With nearly all U.S. colleges and universities offering some form of hybrid, remote, or online learning, recorded lectures have become an important instructional tool. But editing recordings can be tedious, especially for instructors without experience in professional video software.
Text-based editing tools equipped with AI can simplify this process. Rather than manually reviewing and editing recordings, instructors can use searchable transcripts to quickly edit full lectures into clips highlighting key explanations. Agentic AI takes this a step further by handling the entire process, from identifying relevant content to editing and producing. These capabilities can significantly reduce the time and effort required to create supplemental learning materials. As with any edited video, instructors should review the final product before publishing to ensure it feels authentic to the audience they are trying to teach.
In all cases, AI helps educators get started, but human review remains essential to ensure the final product meets instructional needs. The key is for instructors to identify where AI can save time and improve efficiency without adding work.
Evaluating Tools Based on the Task
With new AI capabilities emerging continually, educators need a practical way to determine which tools belong in their workflows. The starting point should be the task, not the technology. A useful approach is to determine whether a task should be automated, augmented by AI, or kept primarily human-led.
- Automate: Use AI for routine, repeatable tasks when outputs can be checked efficiently, and errors have limited consequences.
- Augment: Use AI to support work that still requires an educator’s expertise, such as developing assessments, researching course materials, or refining lesson plans.
- Keep human-led: Retain direct human responsibility for tasks requiring contextual understanding, nuanced evaluation, or consequential decisions.
An interesting aspect of AI is that its views should never stagnate. As tools improve over time, some tasks may become suitable for greater automation. The appropriate level of oversight will also depend on the consequences of an error. AI-generated content can appear polished and complete even when it lacks accuracy, depth, or relevance. Educators should test tools against specific needs and evaluate the quality of their outputs, the frequency of errors, and the time required for review and revision. A tool that generates slides in minutes but requires hours of corrections offers little practical benefit.
When AI can handle tasks, educators have more time to focus on the parts of academia they find most rewarding: engaging with students, exploring research in greater depth, developing new ideas, etc. However, the time saved must outweigh the effort required to review and correct the output. For more complex tasks, AI should support an educator’s work without replacing the expertise needed to assess the results.








