Content and Authority for AI Answers

Why AI Should Create More Opportunities to Practice Judgment

Ascend Learning’s Tushar Tanna offers insights on why AI should create more opportunities to practice judgment. This article originally appeared in Insight Jam, an enterprise IT community that enables human conversation on AI.

Artificial intelligence is changing what it means to be knowledgeable. Tasks that once required hours of research, analysis, or information synthesis can now be completed in seconds. For students, this creates unprecedented access to information and support. For educators, it raises a more fundamental question: If AI can increasingly provide the answers, what skills must students develop to use those answers effectively?

That answer lies in judgment.

Knowing how to retrieve information remains important, but the ability to interpret it, question its reliability, and determine an appropriate course of action is becoming increasingly valuable. In professional environments, particularly those where decisions carry significant consequences, expertise depends on much more than having the right information available.

The real opportunity for AI in education isn’t simply making information easier to access or learning more efficient, which are still very important principles. AI presents the opportunity to fundamentally expand how students develop judgment. Historically, opportunities to practice complex decision-making have been limited by clinical placements available, instructor availability, and general access to real-world experiences. AI can help overcome those constraints by creating dynamic scenarios where students must actively navigate uncertainty and adapt as circumstances change. That could fundamentally change the economics of training judgment by making experiences that once required significant time, faculty involvement, or access to limited environments much easier to deliver to far more students.

These experiences can be highly personalized to each learner, providing targeted opportunities to strengthen specific reasoning and decision-making skills. AI can give students more direct opportunities to wrestle with difficult decisions, learn from their mistakes, and build the confidence required to exercise sound independent judgment. Instead of receiving only a handful of opportunities to practice a complex decision, students could work through repeated variations of a scenario, encounter different outcomes, and build judgment through experience at a scale that was difficult to achieve even a few years ago.

Critical Thinking is Essential as AI Takes on More Tasks 

The growing availability of AI-generated answers introduces a challenge for education: convenience can sometimes come at the expense of deeper engagement. An Elon University survey of 1,057 college faculty found that 95% believe generative AI will increase student overreliance, while 90% believe it will diminish students’ critical thinking skills.

A student might use AI to work through a case study and receive an answer that seems reasonable at first. But what happens if the AI has missed a detail that changes the situation entirely? The student needs to be able to spot that mistake and understand why it matters before deciding what to do next.

A 2025 study from Microsoft Research offers some insight into how reliance on AI can affect critical thinking. Researchers surveyed 319 knowledge workers and found that those who trusted AI more reported putting less effort into critically evaluating its outputs. The opposite was true for workers who had greater confidence in their own abilities. For educators, this raises concern about how much independent thinking students are doing when AI is easily available to help.

The ability to access a credible-sounding answer does not necessarily mean someone understands the reasoning behind it or can recognize when it is incomplete or incorrect.

Therefore, educators must consider how AI can support learning without allowing students to bypass the cognitive processes that build expertise. Students need opportunities to challenge AI-generated recommendations, identify weaknesses in an argument, and explain why a particular decision makes sense, and they can’t do that if they don’t first build their own foundation of knowledge and critical-thinking skills.

Knowing the Answer is Only Part of the Job

As AI changes the skills students need to succeed, educators must also reconsider how they measure learning. Traditional assessments can reveal what students know, but not always how well they can apply that knowledge.

At work, having the right information is only part of making a good decision. Employees also need to recognize when something is missing or when a situation calls for a different approach. These expectations are becoming more common for those just entering the workforce. According to research from Strada Education Foundation, 42% of employers say AI has increased the amount of analytical work and decision-making expected of entry-level employees.

In a nursing simulation, a student might decide on a treatment based on a patient’s symptoms, only to find that the patient’s condition has changed a few minutes later. Now they have to decide whether their original approach still makes sense. The exercise gives them a chance to work through that decision and explain their reasoning before facing a similar situation with a real patient.

Assessment Must Capture How Students Think 

A correct answer in an assessment can yield valuable information about what a student knows, but it does not always reveal how that student arrived at the conclusion. This distinction becomes especially important when AI can generate plausible responses to many traditional assessment questions.

AI-enabled assessment can help educators make these distinctions at scale by using more simulations, branching scenarios, and constructed-response exercises that require students to explain how they reached a decision. AI can also help create variations of those exercises more efficiently, so students have more chances to work through different situations instead of seeing the same type of problem only once.

For example, instead of simply identifying the correct intervention in a clinical scenario, a nursing student might be asked to explain which patient indicators influenced their decision, what alternatives they considered and why they selected a particular course of action.

An assessment could also present an AI-generated recommendation and ask the learner to evaluate its accuracy, identify missing considerations, or explain when following that recommendation would be inappropriate.

As students undertake these new assessment formats, automated feedback and analysis are great tools for observing patterns in student responses and providing more targeted guidance, but educators are still key for interpreting performance, establishing appropriate standards and determining whether learners have demonstrated the judgment required in their field.

Building Clinical Judgment Through Applied Learning 

In nursing, knowing the correct procedure is only part of the job. A patient’s condition can change quickly, and nurses need to recognize when something is wrong, determine what needs immediate attention, and decide how to respond. Preparing students for those moments takes practice that goes beyond memorizing clinical information.

The impact of connecting knowledge acquisition with applied clinical reasoning is already evident in nursing education. At Pinellas Technical College, for example, students’ NCLEX pass rates increased from 70% to 100% within 18 months of implementing a more interactive, practice-oriented learning approach.

While these results should not be attributed to AI alone, they illustrate the importance of educational approaches that prepare students to apply knowledge and demonstrate readiness for professional practice. AI makes it possible to provide those kinds of applied experiences much more broadly. If students are preparing to become nurses, engineers, business leaders or technology professionals, educators should create settings in which learners can repeatedly practice making real-world decisions before facing the consequences of those decisions in the workplace.

Human Skills Define Readiness for an AI-Enabled Workforce 

Judgment is not developed in isolation. It depends on a fusion of technical understanding, communication, collaboration, creativity, and the ability to respond competently under pressure. In a Solutions Review survey of 217 technology professionals, 93% agreed that soft skills would become more important, yet 71% reported having no structured way to assess or improve them at work.

Think about a nurse sitting down with a patient’s family to discuss a change in treatment. AI could help the nurse review the patient’s medical history beforehand. Once the conversation starts, though, the nurse must draw on their own experience to explain the decision, respond to the family’s questions and determine whether they’re comfortable with what comes next.

Technical knowledge alone won’t prepare students for every situation they’ll encounter at work. They also need practice making decisions when the answer isn’t clear, particularly when other people are affected by those decisions. Those lessons are difficult to learn without having to work through the uncertainty themselves.

The goal is to develop learners who can work effectively with AI while building confidence and capability to question its conclusions.

Preparing Students to Think Beyond the Answer 

The expanding capabilities of AI must prompt teachers to reconsider what meaningful learning looks like. Because AI makes information readily available and automates routine tasks, the value of education as a whole is embedded in helping students interpret complexity, exercise judgment, and, overall, apply knowledge in unfamiliar situations.

AI can give students more chances to work through difficult problems and help educators see where they need additional support. That ability to create more frequent and more varied practice may be one of AI’s greatest opportunities in education. Students still need to make their own decisions, explain their reasoning and learn from mistakes, but AI can dramatically expand how often they get to do so.

The measure of successful AI integration in education should not be how quickly students arrive at an answer, but how effectively they learn to determine whether that answer is right, why it matters and what to do next. If AI can help educators create more opportunities to practice those decisions at scale, it can do more than make learning more efficient. It can make meaningful judgment-building experiences available to far more students.

Share This

Related Posts